The blog world today is
full
of
links
to
Edward Tufte's sparklines,
a design element to display time series data in text. Read
the
article, it's interesting.
But as nice as the device of a tiny graph is, I don't think it works
the way he suggests.
I object to his emphasis on "word-size graphics" that "enable them
to be embedded in text and tables".
The last thing I want when reading a paragraph is a tiny
little data display breaking the flow.
The sparklines look fine when they're by
themselves as part of a tabular display. But in the middle of a
paragraph they call too much attention to themselves. And how are you supposed to set a line when one of the "words" is
half the line length and the spacing doesn't break well?
I occasionally worship at the Church of Tufte and have taken a lot of inspiration from his emphasis on simple and clean design. But many of his ideas seem awfully hard to apply well. A particular frustration is that many of Tufte's design elements rely heavily on 1200dpi multi-colour printing on fine paper. That's great, but these days all of my design is for 100dpi computer screens. Tufte has written amazing and comprehensible books that have had a good influence on everyday design. But often when people cite Tufte it's just "oooh, pretty" without really thinking about where the ideas are applicable. |